ConstitutionSecond Schedule, paragraph 153
153. Differently constituted Courts – Justice not seen to be done—The
ratio decidendi of Sip Heng Wong Ng and Ng Ping Man v R (1985) is that
those called upon to return a verdict in a criminal case have “the duty cast
upon them to assess and determine the reliability and veracity of witnesses
who give oral evidence, and it is upon this assessment that their verdict will
ultimately depend”.
Here 3 differently constituted Courts of 2 learned Magistrates each heard
a portion of evidence of witnesses whose testimony was stiffly contested.
Whether or not justice was done in the present case, it was certainly not
seen to be done. Greedhur v R (1987).