ConstitutionSecond Schedule, paragraph 29
29. Reviewing Authority – Powers of amendment – Error as to date of offence charged—The 2 accused were charged before and convicted by the
Profiteering Court for having on 30 March, 1941, committed breaches of
article 22 of GN 73 of 1943. The evidence on record tended to show that
the offences had been committed on 30 March 1943.
HELD the case fell within the purview of Regulation 13 (4) (a) of the Defence (Profiteering Court) Regulations, 1942; that the information charged
CON – 173 [Issue 1]
The Constitution
offences under an enactment which was not in force when the offences
were alleged to have been committed, that the convictions were unreasonable, and, as the Reviewing Authority had no power to amend such convictions, they must be quashed. Per F Herchenroder, Ag J: The circumstances
were such that the convictions were unreasonable and a substantial miscarriage of justice had been committed. Per Le Conte, Ag C J: Under Regulation 13 (4) (a) whenever a point of law has been wrongly decided by the
Profiteering Court, it is only if a substantial miscarriage of justice has occurred that the conviction should be quashed. But no such condition is necessary when, as in the present case, the conviction is (a) unreasonable, and
(b) cannot be supported by the evidence. Chasle v Jalnac (1943).