ConstitutionSecond Schedule, paragraph 38
38. Discretion—The applicant sought leave to appeal against conviction to
the Privy Council. He alleged, inter alia, that it was unconstitutional for the
DPP to choose the trial Court under the Courts Act, section 112, and that
the appellate Court which heard his case was not impartial because one of
its Judges held office at the executive’s pleasure.
Section 112 of the Courts Acts sets out the offences that fall within the
criminal jurisdiction of the Intermediate Court (which includes any offence
that may be tried before a District Magistrate) and lays down that such jurisdiction shall only be exercised on a reference from the Director of Public
Prosecutions. But that section adds nothing to section 72 of the Constitution
which gives the Director the widest discretion to prosecute an offender before
any Court. Their Lordships, in their judgment, met the point Counsel made in
Muktar Ali v R (Privy Council Appeals Nos. 4 and 5 of 1989) by saying “a
discretion in a prosecuting authority to choose the Court before which to
bring an individual charged with a particular offence is not objectionable if
the selection of the punishment to be inflicted on conviction remains at the
discretion of the sentencing Court”. Auchraje v State (1992).