ConstitutionSecond Schedule, paragraph 42
42. Nolle Prosequi – Judicial review of discontinuance by DPP of private
prosecution – Section 72 of Constitution—The applicant made several attempts to lodge a private prosecution against a Minister but they were discontinued by nolle prosequi by the DPP without giving reasons. An application for leave to apply for judicial review of the DPP’s decision was set aside.
Appellant obtained special leave to appeal from the decision of the Supreme
Court to the Judicial Committee.
HELD the DPP cannot rely on the immunity enjoyed by the English
Attorney General when exercising the prerogative power to enter the nolle
prosequi. There was nothing to displace the ordinary assumption that the
DPP as a public officer exercising statutory functions is amenable to judicial
review on specific grounds. The decisions of the Supreme Court were set
aside and the Supreme Court was invited to reconsider the appellant’s applications in the light of this judgment and any evidence there may be, including any reasons the DPP may choose to give. It is for the DPP to decide
whether reasons should be given and, if so, how full they should be. Mohit v
Director of Public Prosecutions (2006).