ConstitutionSecond Schedule, paragraph 51
51. The Imports (Deposits) Regulations, 1977 – Repugnancy to section 8
of the Constitution—A plaintiff who claims redress against an alleged violation of section 8 of the Constitution of Mauritius must first show in terms of
subsection (1) that the subject matter of his plaint is property or an interest
or right over property and that the property has been compulsorily taken
possession of or that the interest or right has been compulsorily acquired,
within the meaning of those expressions in the subsection. When the plaintiff has discharged his burden, the onus is on the defendant to show that the
taking of possession or acquisition of the plaintiff’s property was necessary
for one of the purposes set out in paragraph (a), was justified as required by
paragraph (b), and that the law in virtue of which the taking of possession or
acquisition was effected made provision for the payment of compensation
and access to the Supreme Court as laid down in paragraph (c).
The plaintiff challenged the constitutional validity of the Imports (Deposits) Regulations, 1977, by virtue of which every importer of certain goods is
required to deposit 50% of cif value of the goods with a bank and no interest shall be paid on the deposit.
HELD (i) “property” in section 8 (1) of the Constitution includes money;
(ii) where the taking of money amounts to a forced loan, the compensation for the money taken is the interest payable thereon;
(iii) where the taking of money does not amount to a forced loan, it
would seem that no interest is due if provision is made for the refund of the
money;
(iv) the requirement of the deposit under the Regulations did not
amount to a forced loan, or to a compulsory taking of possession or acquisition within the meaning of section 8 (1) of the Constitution. Hawaldar v
Government of Mauritius (1978).