Mauritius Revenue Authority Act 2004Seventh Schedule, paragraph 21
21. Appeal to Supreme Court
(1) (a) Any party who is dissatisfied with the decision of the Committee under section 20(7), as being
erroneous in law, may lodge in the Registry of the Supreme Court an appeal against that
decision.
(b) Any party wishing to appeal to the Supreme Court under paragraph (a) shall, within 21 days of
the date of the decision of the Committee -
(i) lodge with, or send by registered post to, the Clerk to the Committee a written
application requiring the Committee to state and sign a case for the opinion of the
Supreme Court on the grounds specified in the case; and
* Refer to endnotes at Appendix 1 Page 93 of 118
(ii) at the same time, or earlier, forward a copy of his application by registered post to the
other party.
(1A) A case shall be deemed to have been stated if signed by the Chairperson or any Vice-chairperson.
(2) An appeal under this section shall be prosecuted in the manner provided by rules made by the Chief
Justice.
(3) Notwithstanding an appeal under this section but subject to subsection (4), any tax to be paid or
refunded shall be paid or refunded in accordance with the decision of the Committee, as the case may be.
(4) Where an appeal under this section is lodged against the decision of the Committee relating to a claim
under section 36(1) of the Land (Duties and Taxes) Act or under section 33(4) of the Registration Duty Act, payment of the
tax shall be withheld pending final determination of the matter.
FA 15/2006 – Subsection (3) deleted and replaced w.e.f 07.08.06.
FA 15/2006 – Section 20, Subsection (3) deleted and replaced w.e.f 07.08.06.
MRA Act 2004:-
(3) A panel shall give its decision on the representations heard by it not later than 8 weeks after the start of
the hearing.
MRA Act 2004:-
(3) A panel shall give its decision on the representations heard by it not later than 8 weeks after the start of
the hearing.
MRA Amendment Act No. 4 of 2006 – Section 20, Subsection (1) amended w.e.f 02.10.2004.
MRA Act 2004:-
The aggrieved person and the Director-General, shall be entitled to take part in the hearing, at which no issue
shall be raised other than those set out in the representations made by the person.
MRA Amendment Act No. 4 of 2006 – Section 20, Subsection (4) amended w.e.f 02.10.2004.
MRA Act 2004:-
A decision under subsection (3) which is in respect of any amount of tax to be paid by the aggrieved person shall,
subject to subsection (5), not relieve him from his obligation to pay any surcharge or penalty provided for under
any of the Revenue Laws in respect of a late return or late payment.
MRA Amendment Act No. 4 of 2006 – Section 20, Subsection ( 7 ) amended w.e.f 02.10.2004.
MRA Act 2004:-
The Clerk to the Committee shall arrange for such administrative and secretarial or other assistance as the
Committee or a panel may require and shall forthwith give written notice to the aggrieved person and to the
Director-General of the decision of a Committee.
MRA Amendment Act No. 4 of 2006 – Section 20, Subsection (8) added w.e.f 02.10.2004.
FA 2017 – Section 19, Subsection (1) amended, the word “, with copy to the person against whose decision,
determination, notice or claim the person aggrieved lodges the written representations” inserted after the word
“representations” w.e.f 24 July 2017.
FA 2017 – Section 19, New subsection (1A) inserted after subsection (1) w.e.f 24 July 2017.
FA 2017 – Section 20, Subparagraph (i) amended, the words “6 months” deleted and replaced by the words “2
months” w.e.f 24 July 2017.
* Refer to endnotes at Appendix 1 Page 94 of 118
FA 2017 – Section 20(3), Subparagraph (ii) amended, the words “8 weeks from the start of the hearing” deleted
and replaced by the words “4 weeks from the end of the hearing” w.e.f 24 July 2017.
FA 2018 –Section 19, New subsection (1E) inserted after subsection (1D), shall come into operation on 1
September 2018.
FA 2018 –Section 19, New subsection (2A) inserted after subsection (2) shall come into operation on 1 September
2018.
FA 2019 – Section 19 amended, subsection (1A) repealed and replaced w.e.f 25 July 2019.
Previously-
(1A) (a) Where the written representations referred to in subsection (1) relate to a decision,
determination, notice or claim, as the case may be, under the Income Tax Act, Value Added Tax Act
and Part XXIII of the Gambling Regulatory Authority Act, the written representations shall be
accompanied by –
(i) a statement of case; and
(ii) any witness statement, with copy to the Director-General.
(b) A statement of case shall contain precisely and concisely –
(i) the facts of the case;
(ii) the grounds of the grievances and the arguments relating to each of the grounds;
(iii) submissions on any point of law; and
(iv) any other submissions relevant to the representations.
(c) The statement of case referred to in paragraph (b) shall be made in such form as the Committee
may approve.
FA 2019 – Section 20, Subparagraph (i) amended, the words “within 2 months” deleted and replaced by the words
“within 3 months” w.e.f 25 July 2019
FA 2020 – Section 20, Subsection 3A inserted – w.e.f 7 August 2020
Covid M A 2020- Section 19, New subsection (1E) inserted after subsection (1D) w.e.f 16 May 2020.
Covid M A 2020 – Section 19, The existing subsection (1E) renumbered as (IF) w.e.f 16 May 2020
Covid M A 2020- Section 19, Subsection (2) amended, the word “Where” deleted and replaced by the words
“Notwithstanding subsection (1E), where” – w.e.f 16 May 2020.
FA 2021 - section 19(1F) amended, by deleting the words “section 131B(9)” and replacing them by the words
“section 131B(2)” w.e.f 05 August 2021.
FA 2021 – Section 20, New subsection (7A) inserted after subsection (7) w.e.f 05 August 2021.
FA 2022 – Section 18, Subsection 2 amended, by adding new paragraph (d) w.e.f. 2 August 2022.
FA 2022 – Section 18 amended by adding new subsection (2A), w.e.f. 2 August 2022.
FA 2024 – Section 18, New subsection (2B) added, w.e.f 27 July 2024.
FA 2024 – Section 18, New subsection 18A added w.e.f 27 July 2024.
* Refer to endnotes at Appendix 1 Page 95 of 118
FA 2022 – Section 19 (1A)(a), New subparagraph (iv) inserted after subparagraph (iii), shall come into operation
on 2 September 2022.
FA 2022 – Section 19 (1A)(a), New subparagraph (v) inserted after subparagraph (iv), shall come into operation
on 2 September 2022.
FA 2022 – Section 19 (1A)(a), New subparagraph (vi) inserted after subparagraph (v), shall come into operation
on 2 September 2022.
FA 2022 – Section 19, subsection (1A) amended, paragraph (b) repealed and replaced w.e.f. 2 August 2022.
Previously was:
(b) Where the case is called pro forma under paragraph (a), the Chairperson or Vice-chairperson
shall direct the applicant or his representative to file a statement of case, together with any
witness statement and any relevant document, with copy to the Director-General, within one
month of the pro forma date.
FA 2022 – Section 19, subsection (1A) amended, paragraph (c) repealed and replaced w.e.f. 2 August 2022.
Previously was:
(c) Where the Chairperson or Vice-chairperson is satisfied that it would not be practicable for the
applicant to file the said statement of case and documents, if any, within one month of the pro
forma date, the Chairperson or Vice-chairperson may direct the applicant to file the statement of
case and documents, if any, within a delay to be determined by the Chairperson or Vicechairperson.
FA 2022 – Section 19, subsection (1A) amended, paragraph (d) repealed and replaced w.e.f. 2 August 2022.
Previously was:
(d) The statement of case referred to in paragraph (b) shall be in such form as the Committee may
approve and shall contain precisely and concisely –
(i) the facts of the case;
(ii) the grounds for representations and the arguments relating to each of the grounds;
(iii) submissions on any point of law; and
(iv) any other submissions relevant to the representations.
FA 2022 – Section 19, subsection (1A) amended, paragraph (e) repealed and replaced w.e.f. 2 August 2022.
Previously was:
(e) Where the applicant fails to submit the required statement of case, statement of witness or other
documents, within the delay given by the Chairperson or Vice-chairperson under paragraphs (b)
or (c), and the Chairperson or Vice-chairperson is satisfied that such failure is due to a
reasonable cause, the Chairperson or Vice-chairperson may direct that the said statement of case,
statement of witness or other documents, be filed after the delay referred to in paragraph (b) or
(c).
FA 2022 – Section 19, Subsection (1C) repealed w.e.f. 2 August 2022.
Previously was:
* Refer to endnotes at Appendix 1 Page 96 of 118
Any party served with a copy of the written representations, statement of case and any witness statement shall,
within 21 days of receipt thereof, forward his reply and comments thereon to the Committee, with copy to the
person lodging the written representations.
FA 2022 – Section 19, Subsection (1D) repealed and replaced w.e.f. 2 August 2022
Previously was:
The person lodging the written representations may, within 21 days of receipt of the reply and comments, submit
any reply and comment thereon to the Committee, with copy to the person against whose decision, determination,
notice or claim, as the case may be, representations are made.
FA 2022 – Section 19, New subsection (1DA) inserted after subsection (1D) w.e.f. 2 August 2022.
FA 2022 – Section 19, New subsection (2A) inserted after subsection (2) w.e.f. 2 August 2022.
FA 2022 – Section 19, New subsection (2B) inserted after subsection (2A) w.e.f. 2 August 2022.
FA 2022 – Section 19, New subsection (2C) inserted after subsection (2B) w.e.f. 2 August 2022.
FA 2022 – Section 20, New subsection (3B) inserted after subsection (3A) w.e.f. 2 August 2022.
FA 2024 – Section 18, Existing subsection (2A) repealed and replaced by new subsection (2A). w.e.f 27 July
Previously was:
(2A) Where a panel has started hearing representations under section 20 and a member can no longer form
part of the panel, the Chairperson may, with the consent of the parties to the case, designate another member to
form part of the panel and the reconstituted panel shall continue to hear the representations.
FA 2024 – Setion 20, In Subsection 3(a)(ii), “4 weeks from the end” has been replaced by “6 months from the
start” w.e.f 27 July 2024.
FA 2024 – Section 21, New subsection (1A) inserted after subsection (1) w.e.f 27 July 2024.
FA 2025 – Section 19(1F) amended by inserting, after the words “relate to a determination under”, the words
“section 15(2A)(b), 24(5)(b) or 24A(4)(b) of the Customs Act, section 5(2B)(b) of the Customs Tariff Act, section
5(3)(b), 22(6)(b) or 52(6)(b) of the Excise Act, shall come into operation on 1 October 2025.
72 FA 2021 – Part IVA repealed w.e.f 05 August 2021
Previously was:
PART IVA – INDEPENDENT TAX PANEL72*