ConstitutionSecond Schedule, paragraph 1
1. Principles of democracy – Reference to Electoral Supervisory Commission and to Electoral Commissioner – Relevance of reasonableness and good
faith in relation to amendment of Constitution—The applicants averred that
section 2 of the Constitution of Mauritius (Amendment) Act 1969, which
amended section 57 of the Constitution was null and void because it was
(i) against the spirit of the Constitution, and (ii) in contravention of sections 1, 41 (3) and 57 (2) of the Constitution, and that, consequently, Parliament stood dissolved since 22 August 1972.
HELD (i) by virtue of section 57 (2) of the Constitution, read together
with section 8 (4) of the Mauritius Independence Order, 1968, and section 2
of the Constitution of Mauritius (Amendment) Act 1969, Parliament would
continue in existence, unless sooner dissolved, for 5 years as from the first
sitting of the Legislative Assembly, that is, from 31 July 1971;
(ii) when the Constitution itself permitted the alteration of section 57 which dealt with the prorogation and dissolution of Parliament, and
laid down the procedure for such alteration the alteration when made could
not be said to be contrary to the declaration contained in section 1 of the
Constitution;
(iii) as the proposed Bill for the Act of Parliament to amend section 57 of the Constitution did not relate to the registration of electors for
the election of members of the Assembly, or to the election of such members, it was not necessary to refer it to the Electoral Supervisory Commission
and to the Electoral Commissioner under section 41 (3) of the Constitution;
(iv) whether or not Parliament had acted reasonably and in good
faith when it had altered section 57 of the Constitution was a matter into
which the Court would not enquire; the Court had to satisfy itself that the
alteration had been made in accordance with the procedure laid down in the
Constitution, and that it was not inconsistent with the Constitution. Bérenger
v Governor-General (1973).