ConstitutionSecond Schedule, paragraph 2
2. Constitution of Mauritius (Amendment) Act 1973 – Validity—The petitioners challenged the validity of the Constitution of Mauritius (Amendment)
Act 1973, in so far as it made certain changes in the electoral system, on
the grounds (i) that the Electoral Supervisory Commission had not been afforded sufficient time for considering and commenting upon the Bill for the
Act as required by section 41 (3) of the Constitution; (ii) that the Act offended against the idea of democracy embodied in section 1 of the Constitution and conflicted with other provisions of the Constitution. They also contended that section 5 of the Act should be struck down as being discriminatory in its effect.
HELD dismissing the petition—
(i) the question for the Court was not what time should have been
afforded to the Commission in any circumstances or whether the
Commission could exercise its functions in the time allowed, but
whether it had been as a fact possible for the Commission to
perform those functions within the time at its disposal. In the
CON – 165 [Issue 1]
The Constitution
present instance the evidence established that the Commission
had had sufficient time;
(ii) the power to amend the Constitution conferred upon Parliament
by section 47 was subjected only to the requirements laid down
in that section, that is to say, was conditioned upon the Bill being
supported by a specified number of votes in the Legislative Assembly. Beyond that, no restriction was placed by the Constitution on the amplitude of Parliament’s power to alter its provisions;
(iii) assuming that the provisions of the Act conflicted with other
provisions of the Constitution, there would be no ground in the
inconsistency for invalidating the amending provisions which, if
clear and explicit, must be taken as amending any inconsistent
existing provision, provided the latter provision was one which
could be amended by the procedure required for its alteration
(that is, one passed at the Assembly by the prescribed number
of votes). Lincoln v Governor-General (1974).